- Marketing Career Feature
Survey Says: Don't Fake It
by Anique Gonzalez
by Anique Gonzalez
While learning about marketing — either in the classroom or the boardroom — marketers are taught that influencers are of paramount importance when targeting consumers. Influencers are the market group that will not only buy your product, but motivate others to buy it, as well.
This crowd has social influence over other buyers; therefore, they have the potential to impact the success or failure of a brand. As a result, marketing as a whole has increasingly centered on influencers, usually only a few individuals with the most impact — versus targeting a massive group with little power.
One way marketers do this is by promoting products specifically to influencers so that influencers can create awareness of the product in their community. By encouraging influencers to use certain products, they become advocates for the company/brand/product/service. Especially in the Internet age, the fastest and most effective way to accomplish this, to either encourage or discourage product use, is for influencers to post their experiences or thoughts on community forums.
Attempting to harness such power, marketers have employed new — and sometimes questionable — tactics, such as posing as influencers on afore mentioned community forums. Subsequently, product review sites and community forums, which initially were created so that consumers could voice their approval or displeasure with products or companies, have since been infested with reviews that are posted by companies themselves (or those paid by the company) hoping to combat otherwise negative comments. As influencers have become increasingly aware of this practice, however, they have grown skeptical of the forums themselves and of the companies who employ these strategies.
A recent survey conducted by Burson-Marsteller, for instance, has found that influencers are no longer confident in reviews on community sites because they believe there is a high likelihood that they were posted by biased parties. The study, which was conducted in August, reviewed the attitudes of 1,000 consumers who influence their social networks' habits and purchase decisions, otherwise known as "e-fluentials."
In contrast to results generated five years ago, 30% of respondents said that phony reviews are a major problem. (This is compared to 20% in 2001.) Moreover, 57% of respondents said that they would be far less apt to purchase products from a company who was known to post, or had others post, bogus reviews.
As Ame Wadler, chief strategic officer at Burson, explained, "There's now a skepticism of what is happening online and an expectation [that] if you're in a community site and a commercial entity [is] being discussed, there's someone paid to be weighing in."
This increasing cynicism may in large part be related to the recent gaffes made by companies who tried to create positive word of mouth via online forums. For instance, Wal-Mart initiated a faux blog to generate buzz for the company. Microsoft also gave free laptops as compensation to selected bloggers to experiment with new software and then write about it.
Interestingly, the survey found that influencers not only don't want to be paid for their endorsement of products, but that they look down on those who are compensated. Instead of some type of monetary reward, 52% of these individuals support brands, products, etc., that will invoke some type of change, while 50% simply do this because they want to provide useful information to others.
Ultimately, even in the cut-throat corporate landscape, the old adage holds true: honesty is always the best policy. As Wadler explained, "There's no rocket science here: transparency matters. Those entities that are the most transparent and say, 'It's us, and we're proud of what we're saying,' do far better than those organizations that don't reveal themselves."
On the net:

Burson-Marsteller
www.burson-marsteller.com/default.aspx
Wal-mart
www.walmart.com
Microsoft
www.microsoft.com/en/us/default.aspx
![]() | |
| + Enlarge | |
| Especially in the Internet age, the fastest and most effective way to either encourage or discourage product use is for influencers to post their experiences or thoughts on community forums. |
One way marketers do this is by promoting products specifically to influencers so that influencers can create awareness of the product in their community. By encouraging influencers to use certain products, they become advocates for the company/brand/product/service. Especially in the Internet age, the fastest and most effective way to accomplish this, to either encourage or discourage product use, is for influencers to post their experiences or thoughts on community forums.
Attempting to harness such power, marketers have employed new — and sometimes questionable — tactics, such as posing as influencers on afore mentioned community forums. Subsequently, product review sites and community forums, which initially were created so that consumers could voice their approval or displeasure with products or companies, have since been infested with reviews that are posted by companies themselves (or those paid by the company) hoping to combat otherwise negative comments. As influencers have become increasingly aware of this practice, however, they have grown skeptical of the forums themselves and of the companies who employ these strategies.
A recent survey conducted by Burson-Marsteller, for instance, has found that influencers are no longer confident in reviews on community sites because they believe there is a high likelihood that they were posted by biased parties. The study, which was conducted in August, reviewed the attitudes of 1,000 consumers who influence their social networks' habits and purchase decisions, otherwise known as "e-fluentials."
In contrast to results generated five years ago, 30% of respondents said that phony reviews are a major problem. (This is compared to 20% in 2001.) Moreover, 57% of respondents said that they would be far less apt to purchase products from a company who was known to post, or had others post, bogus reviews.
As Ame Wadler, chief strategic officer at Burson, explained, "There's now a skepticism of what is happening online and an expectation [that] if you're in a community site and a commercial entity [is] being discussed, there's someone paid to be weighing in."
This increasing cynicism may in large part be related to the recent gaffes made by companies who tried to create positive word of mouth via online forums. For instance, Wal-Mart initiated a faux blog to generate buzz for the company. Microsoft also gave free laptops as compensation to selected bloggers to experiment with new software and then write about it.
Interestingly, the survey found that influencers not only don't want to be paid for their endorsement of products, but that they look down on those who are compensated. Instead of some type of monetary reward, 52% of these individuals support brands, products, etc., that will invoke some type of change, while 50% simply do this because they want to provide useful information to others.
Ultimately, even in the cut-throat corporate landscape, the old adage holds true: honesty is always the best policy. As Wadler explained, "There's no rocket science here: transparency matters. Those entities that are the most transparent and say, 'It's us, and we're proud of what we're saying,' do far better than those organizations that don't reveal themselves."
On the net:
Burson-Marsteller
www.burson-marsteller.com/default.aspx
Wal-mart
www.walmart.com
Microsoft
www.microsoft.com/en/us/default.aspx
|
Popular tags:
social networking sites consumers online forums Wal-Mart success social networks potential Internet classrooms |
|||||
|
Comments
article ID: 220204 http://www.marketingcrossing.com/article/220204/Survey-Says-Don-t-Fake-It/ article title: Survey Says: Don't Fake It |
||
| Comment not found for this article. | ||
|
|
||
|
Related articles
|
|
Facebook comments: |
| Show Everyone What You Are Capable Of: Take Action and Investigate Jobs on 50,000+ Websites Instantly |
|
Get immediate results in your job search: Discover marketing jobs from over 50,000 websites on MarketingCrossing. It is not logical for you to be confined to marketing jobs on one website when you can have the exciting experience of searching over 50,000 websites at once. As a highly observant, fast paced and energetic person, you are resourceful and know that it is problematic that job s are scattered on the websites of tens of thousands of companies, organizations and other job boards. By putting this tremendous variety of jobs in one place, we give you flexibility, and empower you to find the job of your choice. Our good-natured approach is one where we do not accept any money from advertisers for job postings; this allows us to provide you with unbiased research about every job opening. You are going to love the variety on our "marketing jobs only" site, the new people you will meet and the fun you will have as a result of taking the initiative and using us. |
|
Tell us where to send your access instructions:
|
|
total jobs on MarketingCrossing |
| 73,136 |
|
new jobs this week on MarketingCrossing |
| 14,194 |
|
total jobs on EmploymentCrossing network available to our members |
| 3,578,520 |
| Get your risk FREE trial |
| jobs near you | |
|
International jobs Work at home jobs |
UK jobs Canada jobs |
|
New search feature using US map. click here
Looking for a new marketing job in your city? click here |
|
| most recent articles |
| Self-Help Means Helping Others |
|
There is a simple concept that separates those who experience great success from those who do not. I am going to tell you all about this concept in a second, but first I want to talk a little bit about self-help. I have read countless books that discuss various methods of improving one’s life and career. I have always found it interesting that these books are almost always classified ... |
|
marketing industry news:
|
recent articles:
|
|
|
| top 5 job searches |
| Marketing job fairs |
|
|||||||||
| Free Report
The Five "Big Dirty Secrets" of Job Sites Just enter your email to get the Report |
![]() |
|||
![]() |







