- Marketing Career Feature
McDonald's Marketing Plan Fails
by Robin Salisian
by Robin Salisian
McDonald's, touting its pervasive slogan, ''I'm loving it,'' isn't feeling the love from local Floridians. After advertising on kids' report cards — good grades equal free food — McDonald's received much disapproval from parents in Seminole County, Florida. Especially from one mother, who fumed, ''The ad offered kids a free Happy Meal for their good work. Shouldn't kids be taught to work for knowledge and pride, not crappy food and imported toys?''
Looks like Ronald McDonald received an F in Marketing.
When parent Susan Pagan discovered the ad, she contacted the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood (CCFC). "My daughter worked so hard to get good grades this term, and now she believes she is entitled to a prize from McDonald's," said Pagan. "And now I'm the 'bad guy' because I had to explain that our family does not eat at fast-food chains. I'm outraged that McDonald's is trying to exploit my daughter's achievement." At once, the CCFC created a campaign to have the advertisement removed.
The ad came wrapped around elementary students' report cards. Students, ranging from kindergarten up to fifth grade, would receive a free Happy Meal for earning A's and B's. A smiling Ronald McDonald led the campaign. However, after the uproar, the yellow and red clown was banished from all report cards. McDonald's agreed to discontinue the ad, reprint the envelopes at no cost to the school, and acknowledge the outcry because "we believe the focus should be on the importance of a good education."
A good education, not a free box of fries and nuggets.
The CCFC and nearly two-thousand parents reigned victorious. As the CCFC's director, Dr. Susan Linn, put it, "This is a good day for parents and children in Seminole County and [for] anyone who believes that corporations should not prey on children in schools. We are pleased that McDonald's is listening to parents all over the country who believe that report cards should not be commercialized."
However, this isn't McDonald's first attempt at directly marketing their products to young kids. According to an article by former fast-food service employee Pratap Chatterjee, "In the 1990s there was a hue and cry by groups like UNPLUG! of Oakland, California, after McDonald's and other companies provided 'sponsored educational materials' on subjects like nutrition to teachers to supplement or take the place of approved curriculum in the U.S. The company was also protested for sponsoring McTeacher's Night in southern California, which involved teachers working at local McDonald's restaurants to raise funds for schools by selling burgers to their own students."
But with another loss tucked under its belt, McDonald's may finally realize that its marketing ploys aimed at children won't get by without a fight. Especially when parents are involved. After all, "One parent can make a difference," said Linn. "And when that parent was joined by other parents and CCFC members, one of our nation's largest corporations was forced to back down. What we accomplished in Seminole County should put all marketers on notice: advertising has no place in our nation's schools."
On the net:

Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood
![]() | |
| + Enlarge | |
| The McDonald's ad came wrapped around elementary students' report cards. Students, ranging from kindergarten up to fifth grade, would receive a free Happy Meal for earning A's and B's. |
When parent Susan Pagan discovered the ad, she contacted the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood (CCFC). "My daughter worked so hard to get good grades this term, and now she believes she is entitled to a prize from McDonald's," said Pagan. "And now I'm the 'bad guy' because I had to explain that our family does not eat at fast-food chains. I'm outraged that McDonald's is trying to exploit my daughter's achievement." At once, the CCFC created a campaign to have the advertisement removed.
The ad came wrapped around elementary students' report cards. Students, ranging from kindergarten up to fifth grade, would receive a free Happy Meal for earning A's and B's. A smiling Ronald McDonald led the campaign. However, after the uproar, the yellow and red clown was banished from all report cards. McDonald's agreed to discontinue the ad, reprint the envelopes at no cost to the school, and acknowledge the outcry because "we believe the focus should be on the importance of a good education."
A good education, not a free box of fries and nuggets.
The CCFC and nearly two-thousand parents reigned victorious. As the CCFC's director, Dr. Susan Linn, put it, "This is a good day for parents and children in Seminole County and [for] anyone who believes that corporations should not prey on children in schools. We are pleased that McDonald's is listening to parents all over the country who believe that report cards should not be commercialized."
However, this isn't McDonald's first attempt at directly marketing their products to young kids. According to an article by former fast-food service employee Pratap Chatterjee, "In the 1990s there was a hue and cry by groups like UNPLUG! of Oakland, California, after McDonald's and other companies provided 'sponsored educational materials' on subjects like nutrition to teachers to supplement or take the place of approved curriculum in the U.S. The company was also protested for sponsoring McTeacher's Night in southern California, which involved teachers working at local McDonald's restaurants to raise funds for schools by selling burgers to their own students."
But with another loss tucked under its belt, McDonald's may finally realize that its marketing ploys aimed at children won't get by without a fight. Especially when parents are involved. After all, "One parent can make a difference," said Linn. "And when that parent was joined by other parents and CCFC members, one of our nation's largest corporations was forced to back down. What we accomplished in Seminole County should put all marketers on notice: advertising has no place in our nation's schools."
On the net:
Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood
|
Popular tags:
Ronald McDonald envelopes smile California United States Happy Meals A's Dr. Susan Linn Seminole County fast food |
|||||
|
Comments
article ID: 220477 http://www.marketingcrossing.com/article/220477/McDonald-s-Marketing-Plan-Fails/ article title: McDonald's Marketing Plan Fails |
||
| Comment not found for this article. | ||
|
|
||
|
Related articles
|
|
Facebook comments: |
| Show Everyone What You Are Capable Of: Take Action and Investigate Jobs on 50,000+ Websites Instantly |
|
Get immediate results in your job search: Discover marketing jobs from over 50,000 websites on MarketingCrossing. It is not logical for you to be confined to marketing jobs on one website when you can have the exciting experience of searching over 50,000 websites at once. As a highly observant, fast paced and energetic person, you are resourceful and know that it is problematic that job s are scattered on the websites of tens of thousands of companies, organizations and other job boards. By putting this tremendous variety of jobs in one place, we give you flexibility, and empower you to find the job of your choice. Our good-natured approach is one where we do not accept any money from advertisers for job postings; this allows us to provide you with unbiased research about every job opening. You are going to love the variety on our "marketing jobs only" site, the new people you will meet and the fun you will have as a result of taking the initiative and using us. |
|
Tell us where to send your access instructions:
|
|
total jobs on MarketingCrossing |
| 73,136 |
|
new jobs this week on MarketingCrossing |
| 14,194 |
|
total jobs on EmploymentCrossing network available to our members |
| 3,578,520 |
| Get your risk FREE trial |
| jobs near you | |
|
International jobs Work at home jobs |
UK jobs Canada jobs |
|
New search feature using US map. click here
Looking for a new marketing job in your city? click here |
|
| most recent articles |
| Self-Help Means Helping Others |
|
There is a simple concept that separates those who experience great success from those who do not. I am going to tell you all about this concept in a second, but first I want to talk a little bit about self-help. I have read countless books that discuss various methods of improving one’s life and career. I have always found it interesting that these books are almost always classified ... |
|
marketing industry news:
|
recent articles:
|
|
|
| top 5 job searches |
| Marketing job fairs |
|
|||||||||
| Free Report
The Five "Big Dirty Secrets" of Job Sites Just enter your email to get the Report |
![]() |
|||
![]() |







