- Marketing Career Feature
Marketing Pioneering Products: Walking the Tightrope Between Enhancing Brand Equity and Committing Genericide
by Surajit Sen Sharma
by Surajit Sen Sharma
The prospect of genericide haunts all strategists trying to market a landmark or groundbreaking product. Beverly W. Pattishall and David C. Hillard used the term "genericide" in 1985 to describe a sequence where superb brand promotion and category dominance end in legal action that declares a brand name "generic." When genericide occurs, the brand attains such a high level of brand promotion that it loses its specific product association and consumers start referring to all commodities in its category by its brand name.
The gate opened for genericide proceedings in the U.S. with a case involving Aspirin. The bench held that if the common consumer perceived the word representing the brand name to stand for a category of products and not the particular product, then irrespective of the advertiser's efforts to clear confusion, the brand name was generic (Kane 1991). Since then, the list of brand names that have become casualties of genericide has kept on growing; today, it includes pioneering brands like Trampoline, Escalator, Linoleum, Cellophane, Thermos, Corn Flakes, and, of course, Aspirin.
In the U.S., the Lanham Act of 1946 excludes "any common descriptive word of any article" from being registered as a trademark and, therefore, as a brand name. The 1988 Trademark Revision Act provides that the owner of a generic trademark shall lose the right to exclusive use for its own product or products. The act says, "A mark shall be abandoned when any course of conduct of the owners causes the mark to become a generic name for the goods or services on or in connection with which it is used." Similar legislation is also present in other countries.
The legal effects of genericide prevent the marketer from reserving its brand name or its marketing message for its own product. Competitors become empowered to associate a generic brand name with their own products and destroy category dominance by dilution. Marketing history has shown that most often, pioneering products fall prey to the phenomenon of genericide. The most-cited precedent happened in 1938 when Kellogg had to give up its right to use the term "shredded wheat" (Kellogg Co. v. Nabisco Biscuit Co.).
It was fear of genericide that reportedly made Xerox Corp. muse about a name change in the 90s. It is this same fear that makes Xerox run at least one advertisement per year devoted to dispelling the association of its brand name with the entire product category (Lans 1994).
Genericide can be prevented if marketers:
Fear of genericide has led brands like Kleenex, Rolodex, Coca-Cola, Styrofoam, Kitty Litter, Astroturf, and Laundromat, among others, to employ intellectual property lawyers in regular battles against genericide, and such brands often adopt marketing strategies geared to put a stop to consumer confusion. Thus, a marketer of a pioneering product cannot afford to ignore this issue.
Works Cited
Kane, Siegrun D. Trademark Law: A Practitioner's Guide. New York: Practicing Law Institute, 1991.
Kellogg Co. v. Nabisco Biscuit Co. (1938). 305 US 111, 118, 39 USPQ 296, 299.
Lans, Maxine S. "On Your Mark: Get Set or It May Go." Marketing News, September 1994.
Pattishall, Beverly W., and David C. Hillard. Unfair Competition and Unfair Trade Practices. New York: Matthew Bender, 1985.
On the net:

Coca-Cola
www.coca-cola.com
Kleenex
www.kleenex.com
Kellogg's
www.kelloggs.com
![]() | |
| + Enlarge | |
| In marketing, you must find a balance between brand equity and genericide. |
In the U.S., the Lanham Act of 1946 excludes "any common descriptive word of any article" from being registered as a trademark and, therefore, as a brand name. The 1988 Trademark Revision Act provides that the owner of a generic trademark shall lose the right to exclusive use for its own product or products. The act says, "A mark shall be abandoned when any course of conduct of the owners causes the mark to become a generic name for the goods or services on or in connection with which it is used." Similar legislation is also present in other countries.
The legal effects of genericide prevent the marketer from reserving its brand name or its marketing message for its own product. Competitors become empowered to associate a generic brand name with their own products and destroy category dominance by dilution. Marketing history has shown that most often, pioneering products fall prey to the phenomenon of genericide. The most-cited precedent happened in 1938 when Kellogg had to give up its right to use the term "shredded wheat" (Kellogg Co. v. Nabisco Biscuit Co.).
It was fear of genericide that reportedly made Xerox Corp. muse about a name change in the 90s. It is this same fear that makes Xerox run at least one advertisement per year devoted to dispelling the association of its brand name with the entire product category (Lans 1994).
Genericide can be prevented if marketers:
- Make immediate formal objections to any misuse of their trademark by anyone. Such misuse includes improper usage in the media and common-noun or verb references in dictionaries or encyclopedias.
- Run periodic campaigns to counteract consumer confusion.
- Devise the marketing mix of a pioneering product, from its very beginning, in a manner that eliminates the chance of any generic attachment to the brand name. (The marketing strategy of Microsoft Windows is a good example in this regard. Windows definitely ran the risk of gaining generic status with respect to PC operating systems, but a carefully planned marketing strategy has kept this potential problem at bay.)
Fear of genericide has led brands like Kleenex, Rolodex, Coca-Cola, Styrofoam, Kitty Litter, Astroturf, and Laundromat, among others, to employ intellectual property lawyers in regular battles against genericide, and such brands often adopt marketing strategies geared to put a stop to consumer confusion. Thus, a marketer of a pioneering product cannot afford to ignore this issue.
Works Cited
Kane, Siegrun D. Trademark Law: A Practitioner's Guide. New York: Practicing Law Institute, 1991.
Kellogg Co. v. Nabisco Biscuit Co. (1938). 305 US 111, 118, 39 USPQ 296, 299.
Lans, Maxine S. "On Your Mark: Get Set or It May Go." Marketing News, September 1994.
Pattishall, Beverly W., and David C. Hillard. Unfair Competition and Unfair Trade Practices. New York: Matthew Bender, 1985.
On the net:
Coca-Cola
www.coca-cola.com
Kleenex
www.kleenex.com
Kellogg's
www.kelloggs.com
|
Popular tags:
trademarks groundbreaking owners advertising commodity United States landmarks details consumers |
|||||
|
Comments
article ID: 220041 http://www.marketingcrossing.com/article/220041/Marketing-Pioneering-Products-Walking-the-Tightrope-Between-Enhancing-Brand-Equity-and-Committing-Genericide/ article title: Marketing Pioneering Products: Walking the Tightrope Between Enhancing Brand Equity and Committing Genericide |
||
| Comment not found for this article. | ||
|
|
||
|
Related articles
|
|
Facebook comments: |
| Show Everyone What You Are Capable Of: Take Action and Investigate Jobs on 50,000+ Websites Instantly |
|
Get immediate results in your job search: Discover marketing jobs from over 50,000 websites on MarketingCrossing. It is not logical for you to be confined to marketing jobs on one website when you can have the exciting experience of searching over 50,000 websites at once. As a highly observant, fast paced and energetic person, you are resourceful and know that it is problematic that job s are scattered on the websites of tens of thousands of companies, organizations and other job boards. By putting this tremendous variety of jobs in one place, we give you flexibility, and empower you to find the job of your choice. Our good-natured approach is one where we do not accept any money from advertisers for job postings; this allows us to provide you with unbiased research about every job opening. You are going to love the variety on our "marketing jobs only" site, the new people you will meet and the fun you will have as a result of taking the initiative and using us. |
|
Tell us where to send your access instructions:
|
|
total jobs on MarketingCrossing |
| 73,136 |
|
new jobs this week on MarketingCrossing |
| 14,194 |
|
total jobs on EmploymentCrossing network available to our members |
| 3,578,520 |
| Get your risk FREE trial |
| jobs near you | |
|
International jobs Work at home jobs |
UK jobs Canada jobs |
|
New search feature using US map. click here
Looking for a new marketing job in your city? click here |
|
| most recent articles |
| Self-Help Means Helping Others |
|
There is a simple concept that separates those who experience great success from those who do not. I am going to tell you all about this concept in a second, but first I want to talk a little bit about self-help. I have read countless books that discuss various methods of improving one’s life and career. I have always found it interesting that these books are almost always classified ... |
|
marketing industry news:
|
recent articles:
|
|
|
| top 5 job searches |
| Marketing job fairs |
|
|||||||||
| Free Report
The Five "Big Dirty Secrets" of Job Sites Just enter your email to get the Report |
![]() |
|||
![]() |







